Same corrosion, different decisions: corrosion response criteria for onshore pipelines in the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Operators of onshore pipelines in North America and Europe assess the same in-line inspection (ILI) data against different rules. This paper compares, on one common basis, the corrosion response criteria of current and proposed United States regulations for hazardous liquid and gas transmission pipelines, the Canadian standard CSA Z662 and United Kingdom guidance. Each criterion is expressed in terms of reported depth, axial length and failure pressure ratio, computed with Modified B31G, and the resulting decision boundaries are drawn for one pipe at common operating stresses. A 10 km ILI data set from a pipeline built in 1960 serves as a worked illustration. The order of the pressure thresholds reverses with product and location class: Canadian criteria are less demanding than United States rules for some liquid lines and more demanding for gas lines in Class 3. Depth and feature-type rules act where pressure rules do not. On the illustrative line, which contains only shallow corrosion, no pressure criterion is met; all differences come from depth rules and from the United Kingdom screening limit, whose outcome depends on corrosion classification and sizing tolerance, neither of which the rules define. Preprint (author's original manuscript) submitted to Safety and Reliability (Taylor & Francis) on 16 November 2026; not peer reviewed.
Author: Ibragimov, Eduard
Language: English
Subfield: Mechanical Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7233996005
