Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: A regional regulation that implements a statutory provision cannot sensibly operate before that provision does. This article documents a case in which four Indonesian provinces enacted implementing instruments that took effect approximately one year before the statutory provisions they implement. Law No. 1 of 2022 took general effect on promulgation but deferred its provisions on motor vehicle taxation and the local surcharge by three years under Article 191(1), to 5 January 2025, while Article 187(c) preserved regional regulations made under the repealed law for the same interval. Four provinces nevertheless brought their new instruments into force in January 2024. The result is an interval of approximately twelve months in which two instruments both claimed to govern the same tax: a preserved regulation whose statutory basis had been repealed but whose validity was extended, and a new regulation whose statutory basis existed but had not yet commenced. The article argues that the difficulty is not one of conflict between norms but of a transitional scheme that fixed two dates independently and did not state which governs the overlap, and that a commencement provision deferring substantive articles should carry a matching direction to the instruments made under them.
Author: Najwa Nisriina Khairunnisa
Institution: Universitas Pamulang
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234026130
