The Unasked Experiment: How Scientific AI May Narrow the Space of Discoverable Knowledge
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The increasing participation of artificial intelligence in scientific research shifts some consequential epistemic decisions from human investigators to automated selection procedures. Systems may propose hypotheses, rank candidate experiments, allocate scarce resources, interpret observations, and report findings. Yet the adequacy of a completed experiment does not, by itself, establish the adequacy of the choices that excluded other experiments. This conceptual paper examines the scientific status of identifiable experimental alternatives that were considered but not executed. Its central distinction separates justified prioritization, insufficiently warranted exclusion, unrecoverable selection histories, and possibilities that were never generated at all. Drawing on active learning, Bayesian experimental design, autonomous scientific discovery, causal inquiry, and research-integrity literature, the paper proposes an Experimental Exclusion Warrant (EEW): a bounded, claim-relative specification of a non-execution decision and the evidence necessary to reassess it. Three illustrative tables and two conceptual figures differentiate the object of inquiry, its strongest conventional alternatives, and a prospective information-matched evaluation. Four adversarial thought experiments show why successful prediction need not settle explanatory adequacy, why missing logs do not prove a missed opportunity, and why ordinary research auditing may already suffice. The contribution is a limited methodological synthesis, not a discovery of an unknown selection bias, a novel mathematical theorem, or an empirically validated intervention. No new experiments were conducted. The proposed account warrants further consideration only insofar as it makes particular exclusion decisions more contestable than competent existing methods and remains capable of concluding that no additional framework is needed.
Author: Figurelli, Rogério
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234060021
