Gods, Games and the Giving Environment: Spirit Beliefs and Cooperation among BaYaka Hunter-Gatherers
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: To advance our knowledge of religious systems, we need to understand how religious beliefs are structured in society, and the impact these beliefs have on subsequent behaviour (e.g., cooperation), particularly in small-scale societies such as hunter-gatherers. Here, we adopt a two-study approach to examine this topic among BaYaka foragers. In study 1, we use a “quantitative ethnographic” approach to describe how beliefs regarding deities are structured in the population. We found that: i) there are marked gender differences in the salience of deities, corresponding to gender roles; ii) many deities are specific to individuals who they share a personal relationship with; and iii) most deities are perceived to be morally-concerned. These results then informed study 2, where we used a causal inference approach to assess whether supernatural punishment beliefs regarding a “local” (i.e., less punitive, omniscient, and morally-concerned) deity promote cooperation with distant co-religionists of the same local religious tradition using experimental games. We found little evidence for a causal effect, largely because BaYaka game behaviour was scrupulously fair—to the extent they would break the game’s rules to achieve equality—likely due to the influence of strong sharing and fairness norms. Using ethnographically- and causally-informed quantitative methods, this study provides insight into the structure of BaYaka religious beliefs, and the impact of these supernatural punishment beliefs regarding “local” deities on cooperation with distant co-religionists.
Source: SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234062781
