Work

Diagnosing Policy Process Imbalance in Multi-level Governance Evidence From Indonesia's Policy Quality Index (IKK) 2025

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Public policy quality is determined not only by outcomes but also by the consistency across stages in the policy cycle. However, in practice, policies often exhibit reactive tendencies that indicate process imbalances, particularly at the planning stage. This study aims to analyze policy cycle imbalance in Indonesia using the 2025 Policy Quality Index as a policy process diagnostic tool. The study employs a quantitative descriptive approach based on a composite index covering 468 government institutions and 1379 policies through comparative analysis across dimensions and the measurement of the Policy Imbalance Index. The findings show that the planning dimension at 56.05 and the evaluation and sustainability dimension at 57.64 are consistently lower than implementation at 62.87 and transparency and public participation at 67.07, with a Policy Imbalance Index value of 4.06 indicating a moderate imbalance in the policy cycle. These results suggest limited analytical capacity at the ex-ante stage, contributing to reactive policymaking tendencies as well as disparities in policy capacity across governance levels. This study contributes theoretically by extending the role of the policy quality index as a policy process diagnostic tool to identify structural dysfunctions across policy stages. Practically, it highlights the need to strengthen datadriven planning, stakeholder involvement, impact analysis, and evaluation functions to promote more anticipatory and evidence-based policymaking.
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7234146883
FWCI:
Cites: 25
Cited by:
Related to: 10