When the Strands Disagree: Using Divergence in Mixed-Methods Joint Displays to Refine Practical Frameworks
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Joint displays, which set quantitative and qualitative findings side by side, have become a standard device for integrating results in mixed-methods research. In practice, researchers tend to report convergence and to explain away divergence by attributing it to a weakness in one strand. This methodological paper argues that divergence is frequently the most informative product of a joint display and shows how it can be used to refine a practical framework. The argument is developed through a worked example from a mixed-methods study of expatriate educator retention in international high schools in Guangzhou, China, in which a survey of 52 educators was integrated with written interviews with 11. Ten domains were classified as convergent, complementary, divergent or qualitative only: five converged, three were complementary, one diverged and one emerged only in the interviews.
Authors: Issah Quarmson, Maria Sonia Justin Raj
Institutions: Westford University College, Universidad Católica de Murcia
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7234147145
