Thirteen is the first path counterexample to Malkoun's real-part conjecture
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This preprint determines the first path size at which Malkoun's real-part conjecture fails. The conjectured real-part inequality holds for every configuration of P_n with 2 <= n <= 12, whereas every P_n with n >= 13 admits a counterexample. The positive theorem includes a quantitative bending bound and a complete equality characterization. Its computer-assisted proof reduces P_12 to a five-step projection inequality and verifies an exact rational sum-of-squares certificate in eighteen real variables. Four positive definite Gram blocks, nine equality multipliers and all 1875 coefficient positions are checked with integer arithmetic. The negative result uses thirteen distinct rational points and is independently verified by all 2048 original local edge contractions. The supplement contains the essential certificates, full rational data, editable source and a standalone Python standard-library checker. The minimum is within the family of paths; no minimum among all trees is asserted. Conceptual origin and AI assistance The initial idea and conceptual starting point of this investigation are based on the framework of the original geometric paper by Christos Panorias and Kostandina Theodhori, Canonical Parametric Representation of Plane Euclidean Geometry (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23837735). This attribution concerns the conceptual origin and methodological organization of the research; every mathematical premise required by the present proofs is stated explicitly here. OpenAI ChatGPT/Codex assisted verification of calculations, editorial polishing and selected, delimited arguments during proof development, including substantive mathematical reasoning in those arguments. Christos Panorias is the sole named author and retains responsibility for reviewing, adopting and submitting the mathematical claims and final text. Rights: Copyright © 2026 Christos Panorias. All rights reserved. Personal reading and scholarly evaluation of this manuscript are permitted. The accompanying original code may be executed and locally modified for private scholarly evaluation. Redistribution, publication of adaptations, republication and commercial reuse of copyright-protected material require prior written permission, except as permitted by applicable law. These terms cover the original text, figures and code, and do not claim exclusive rights over mathematical facts, ideas or methods. Cited works and software dependencies retain their own rights.
Author: Panorias, Christos
Language: English
Topic: Mathematics and Applications
Subfield: Geometry and Topology
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234161957
