Work

From Epistemic Support to Argumentative Accessibility: A Linguistic Interface for the Epistemological Theory of Argumentation

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The epistemological theory of argumentation defines a good argument by its epistemic function: it supplies the addressee with a basis that justifies accepting the conclusion. This function is grounded in a support relation between premises and conclusion. Siegel and Lumer both defend the centrality of this relation, yet the linguistic conditions under which an addressee recovers it remain underdeveloped within the theory. Lumer recognizes addressee accessibility as a condition of argumentative adequacy, though he does not develop it as a graded dimension systematically related to the linguistic realization of an argument. This paper develops argumentative accessibility as the degree to which the inferential relation linking premises to conclusion is recoverable from an argument’s linguistic realization in context. It proposes a comparative criterion based on the components of the relation that a formulation makes recoverable, and it distinguishes inferential cueing, which facilitates recovery, from strength cueing, which signals how strongly the conclusion is supported. Constructed contrasts that hold propositional content and stipulated support constant establish the conceptual distinctness of support and accessibility, without any claim that accessibility is an empirically independent psychological variable. The distinction grounds a norm of calibration: the strength a formulation signals should be proportionate to the support its reasons provide, and the support relation should be sufficiently accessible for the intended addressee to evaluate it. The account thus extends the epistemological theory by connecting epistemic support to its linguistic presentation, and it maintains that epistemic priority does not entail linguistic independence.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234168086
Cites: 18
Cited by:
Related to: 10