Revising the imposter phenomenon: a social perspective on the development and manifestation of the imposter phenomenon among medical students
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Imposter Phenomenon (IP) describes the internal experience of perceived intellectual insincerity, marked by fear of exposure as an intellectual fraud. Research underscores a high prevalence amongst medical students. To date, IP has largely been recognised as an internal, psychological experience. This study expands this perspective by exploring the complex social environments that shape the development, manifestation, and perpetuation of IP. It offers a novel dimension to understanding IP within the context of medical education. A mixed methods approach was employed, combining quantitative data from 315 survey respondents with qualitative insights from focus group discussions. 71.7% of respondents experienced clinically significant IP (CIPS ≥ 62), with female students reporting higher median scores (73.00) than males (66.50, p = .003). Reflexive thematic analysis identified four interrelated contextual factors shaping students’ experiences of IP (1) societal expectations and cultures (2) societal stereotypes (3) workplace and school culture (4) meritocratic environments. These factors intersected with internal psychological processes, informing the proposed Doubt-Dread Cycle of self-doubt, perceived inadequacy and fear of failure. This study conceptualises IP as a dynamic interaction between internal dispositions and external social forces, operating on a continuum of severity influenced by an individual’s environment. By situating IP within the socio-cultural context of medical education, this study highlights a need for both structural and cultural interventions that distribute responsibility across individuals, institutions, and the broader educational environment. This shared accountability promotes a more equitable model of medical education that acknowledges diverse learner identities, fosters a more supportive professional and educational environment, and ultimately reduces the negative impact of IP for our future doctors in training.
Source: Medical Education Online
Authors: William Pallett, Emma Black, David Thewlis
Institution: Newcastle University
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,189
OpenAlex ID: W7234203605
