Work

PCA-Based Labeling of Student Academic and Non-Academic Achievement: A Comparison of Data Transformation Methods

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Variance preservation does not necessarily establish meaningful achievement categories. This study compares six data transformations for principal component analysis (PCA)-based labeling using records from SMAN 1 Kertosono in 2024/2025. Academic data comprise 216 semester observations from 108 students in Grades XXII; non-academic data comprise 144 observations from 72 students in Grades XXI. Normalizer, StandardScaler, MinMaxScaler, MaxAbsScaler, RobustScaler, and QuantileTransformer were evaluated using student-grouped nested cross-validation. Transformations were selected by inner-validation macro F1 against teacher assessments. PCA fitting, sign orientation of the first principal component (PC1), and estimation of the one-third and two-thirds quantiles were confined to training data. These quantiles defined Low, Medium, and High categories for held-out students. MaxAbsScaler was selected in all five academic development sets, yielding 73.15% accuracy, macro F1 of 0.7233, and Cohen's kappa of 0.5982. Academic PC1 explained 81.0782.16% of transformed training variance, but labeling did not outperform the raw-score tertile baseline. Non-academic selections varied across folds, yielding 27.78% accuracy, macro F1 of 0.2377, and kappa of 0.0904. Non-academic PC1 explained 17.4827.86% of variance and primarily contrasted activity profiles, limiting its interpretation as an achievement scale. The contribution is an empirical evaluation separating variance retention, component interpretation, and teacher agreement. Results support a limited descriptive interpretation of academic PC1 but do not support the current non-academic categories as an overall achievement ranking. Findings are restricted to one school and require independent validation.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $110
OpenAlex ID: W7234215619
FWCI:
Cites: 9
Cited by:
Related to: 10