Validating a quadcopter frame when the build departs from the design: finite-element analysis, bend testing and flight trials
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This technical note revisits a second-year undergraduate project (University of Hertfordshire, 2024) in which a 400 mm quadcopter frame was designed, analysed with a linear finite-element model in CATIA, tested in three-point bending and flown. A manufacturing error meant that the frame that flew was not the frame that had been designed: the carbon-fibre parts were cut with misaligned motor holes, and the structure was rebuilt in medium-density fibreboard (MDF). The note sets out which results belong to which structure, compares the finite-element model with the bend test over the range where both exist, and states what the surviving records do not support. For the design-stage frame, the model agreed with the measured centre displacement within 2% at 15 N and under-predicted it by about 8% at 20 N. For the rebuilt MDF and carbon-fibre test article, the model under-predicted displacement by about 15% at 70 N. The flown MDF frame completed two flights of about 30 s and a 3 m drop test, in which the structure was damaged. The main lesson is about validation: agreement at a single load point overstated how well the model had been checked, and the structure that flew was never itself tested. Limitations are reported in full, including the absence of a mesh-convergence study and unusable stress results. No new results are added to the original coursework; the note corrects and clarifies the record.
Author: Raut, Sarth
Language: English
Topic: Engineering Applied Research
Subfield: Civil and Structural Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234221155
