A technical assessment of the funding threshold in Nayebi (2026)
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This technical note works through the model of Nayebi (2026), "When do AI gains become broadly shareable? A policy threshold for AI-driven automation" (AIES 2026; proofs in arXiv:2505.18687). It uses only the equations and the calibration of that paper, together with the definition of the benefit given in the author's AIES 2026 poster. It asks which conclusions about the funding threshold hold, and under which assumptions. The note reaches five results. (1) In the production function of the paper, GDP depends on AI productivity and on capital only through the AI income share. For given capital and labour, higher AI productivity lowers GDP, and AI income has an upper limit at every date. (2) The reported threshold of 5.6 is computed at a point where the funding condition requires an AI income share of 190%, while the share is always below 100%. (3) With the fixed benefit and the capital rule of the paper, only one constant growth factor of AI productivity is compatible with balanced growth, 0.375% a year. On that path the AI income share stays at 14.1% and the benefit is funded after 236.4 years with the current public share. (4) On any path, the benefit cannot be funded before 202.8 years with the current public share, or 127.1 years with a one-third share. (5) At a given date the funding condition is two-sided: AI productivity can be too high as well as too low. These are properties of the model as written and calibrated. They are not forecasts. The role of the public share and of the cost share in the funding condition of the paper is unchanged. The note also shows that the long-run convergence of capital/output stated in the appendix of the paper is correct when AI productivity is constant. This is a working paper and has not been peer reviewed. It is a separate study in the same research programme as "Intelligence Scales, Matter Does Not" (De Joannon 2026). It assesses a model cited in the literature review of that paper and does not change its propositions.
Author: De Joannon, Alfredo
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234225009
