GW200129 Recoil: Pricing the Claimed Large Kick Against the Mass-Asymmetry Term
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: GW200129, a near-equal merger of about 34.5 and 29.6 solar masses, became the subject of a published claim that its remnant recoiled at more than one thousand kilometres per second, driven by strongly precessing spins. If correct, the remnant would escape any globular cluster and most galactic potentials. The budget prices the claim's two parts separately. The mass-asymmetry term is computed exactly from the fitting formula and is small at this ratio. The remainder must come from spin geometry, so the budget states the spin scenario the claim requires and compares the total against escape speeds, without endorsing or rejecting the underlying waveform analysis. Headline values are kick129 chirp solar kick129 = 27.8; kick129 det chirp solar kick129 = 32.81; kick129 pub radiated solar kick129 = 3.2; kick129 fit radiated solar kick129 = 3.157; kick129 radiated frac kick129 = 0.04925; kick129 radiated joules kick129 = 5.64e+47. The escape comparison is drawn at one thousand kilometres per second because that is the scale at which even galactic nuclei begin to lose remnants, making the claim's consequence binary rather than gradual.
Author: Aldred, William Alexander
Language: English
Subfield: Astronomy and Astrophysics
Field: Physics and Astronomy
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234277077
