Konstytucyjne granice arbitrażu i mediacji w Kodeksie postępowania cywilnego dwadzieścia lat po reformie z 2005 r.
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The paper offers a doctrinal and constitutional assessment of arbitration and mediation in the Polish Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) twenty years after the 2005 reform that embedded ADR within the civil justice system. UNCITRAL model laws serve as the principal benchmark for “soft” procedural harmonisation. The main argument is that Polish arbitration law largely remains compatible with the UNCITRAL architecture (party autonomy, competence-competence, limited judicial intervention), yet selected amendments adopted in 2023–2025 shift the balance towards discretionary ex ante judicial control, potentially undermining constitutional values of legal certainty and equality in access to legal protection. With regard to mediation, the critical issue is the incentive structure: procedural and cost-related incentives must remain within the limits of the right to a court and proportionality. The study combines doctrinal analysis with functional and comparative considerations (England – the Arbitration Act 2025 and Germany – modernisation of arbitration law and the development of commercial courts).
Source: Przegląd Konstytucyjny
Author: Michał Peno
Institution: University of Szczecin
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: arbitration, mediation (conflict resolution), Polish Code of Civil Procedure, alternative dispute resolution, UNCITRAL Model Law, party autonomy, competence-competence, judicial intervention in arbitration, legal certainty, access to justice, right to a court, proportionality, commercial courts
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7234280491
