Work

Peer versus teacher-assigned medical student grades

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Background Teachers evaluate students’ academic progress and performance in the conventional education system. However, recent studies suggest that peer assessment offers a range of learning benefits and can effectively complement traditional sole teacher assessment. We evaluated the effectiveness of peer assessment alongside traditional teacher assessment in medical education. Methods Students were tasked with framing a set of questions for a chosen topic. A question paper was then created from the question bank. A pre-validated answer key with subdivisions of scores was prepared. Following the written examination, the answer key was displayed and used for the correction of anonymized answer papers, first by a peer and then by a teacher. This entire exercise was repeated for a different topic, providing comprehensive feedback. The scores allotted by the peers and teachers were then compared. Results On test 1, among the 94 students, the mean (standard deviation [SD]) score was 20.99 (4.30) for peer assessment and 20.72 (4.10) for teacher assessment. On test 2, the mean (SD) score was 22.22 (7.37) and 23.35 (5.81) for peer and teacher assessment, respectively. For each test, the correlation between peers and teacher grades was found to be 0.77 and 0.60. Conclusion Students are capable of designing a concise, valid, open-ended question paper. The difference in scores between the two evaluators was found to be minimal. Given the numerous advantages of peer assessment, we suggest incorporating peer assessment as an additional method to evaluate student performance.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234319015
FWCI:
Cites: 28
Cited by:
Related to: 10