Work

Counting the Incubator: Evidence Standards for Efficiency Claims in Biological Computing

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Claims that living neural tissue computes more efficiently than silicon rest on an analogy — the human brain runs on about 20 W — rather than on a measurement. This article shows that the analogy commits a category error: it compares a whole brain with a millimetre-scale culture, tissue metabolism with system power, and invokes efficiency without naming a task. It then proposes evidence standards that make the question decidable. An energy standard requires measurement at the wall, normalisation per task at fixed accuracy, comparison against the best equivalent silicon baseline, attribution controls, reproducibility across cultures, amortisation over the tissue’s working life, and separation of projection from measurement. A necessary condition follows: interfacing and tissue production are per-unit costs that scale cannot dilute, so no amount of parallelism rescues a system that fails it. A five-level evidence ladder states which claim each level of evidence licenses; applying it to the published record located by a targeted search in November 2026, no result exceeds the lowest two levels for energy, although several demonstrate learning. The analysis is then extended to proposals that would use human brains as computational substrate, where an isolation trilemma leaves no known path. A reporting checklist closes the article.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234344378
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10