Work

Measurement of Success without Measures: A Critical Review of Performance Indicators and the Strategy - Performance Link among Small and Medium Enterprises in Kabwe District, Zambia

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in Zambia are widely reported to fail or stagnate, yet owner-managers routinely describe their firms as successful. This paradox raises a prior question that strategy research seldom asks: how is SME performance conceptualized and measured, and can the measures in use carry the inferential weight placed on them? This paper critically appraises the performance indicators SMEs in Kabwe District, Central Province, Zambia, use and examines whether those indicators are empirically linked to the strategic management practices (SMPs) theorised to drive performance. Grounded in Resource-Based Theory and Dynamic Capabilities Theory, the study adopted a concurrent mixed-methods design. Structured questionnaires were completed by 202 owner-managers of registered SMEs (response rate 91.8%), and semi-structured interviews were held with 100 of them. We examined six indicators: sales target attainment, profitability, customer satisfaction, product and service quality, revenue and market-share growth, and employee satisfaction. Quantitative data were analyzed using exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis and bootstrapped mediation analysis; qualitative data were analyzed using directed content analysis. The six indicators formed a reliable, convergent construct (Cronbach’s α = 0.888; AVE = 0.670), and between 94.6% and 100% of respondents agreed that their firms met each indicator. However, reported performance was statistically unrelated to environmental scanning, strategy formulation, strategy implementation, and strategy evaluation and control (r = −0.137 to 0.002); no model explained more than 3.3% of the variance in performance, and innovation was negatively associated with reported performance (b ≈ −0.31, p < .05). Interviews revealed the mechanism: owner-managers invoked sales, profits and customers as measures but could not quantify any of them. The study makes four contributions. Theoretically, it shows that the feedback loop assumed by Resource-Based and Dynamic Capabilities theories is open, where performance is not measured, positioning performance measurement as a micro-foundation of sensing capability. Methodologically, it demonstrates that a perceptual scale can pass conventional psychometric tests yet fail a substantiation test. Practically, it recommends that SME support programmes build record-based measurement before strategy training. Contextually, it extends SME strategy research to an under-studied post-mining district. As a cross-sectional study of registered, surviving firms, the findings are associational and bounded to that population
Language: English
Subfield: Accounting
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W7234349661
FWCI:
Cites: 27
Cited by:
Related to: 10