Reskilling Versus Replacement under Technological Change and the Future of Employment Relations
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Purpose: Rapid technological innovation makes skills obsolete faster and forces organizations to choose between replacing employees through external hiring and reskilling and redeploying incumbents. This article examines how these strategic workforce responses affect organizational value and employment relations outcomes under different technological, labor market, and employment relations conditions. Research Methodology: An agent based model of an organization with 500 employees was developed, in which technology depreciates skills and trust shapes effort, training participation, and turnover. Four strategies, namely passive adaptation, buy, make, and hybrid reskilling with redeployment, were compared over ten years across 48 scenarios that combine technology intensity, labor market tightness, and adversarial or partnership based employment relations. Results: Internal development strategies (make or hybrid) produced a higher Net Present Value (NPV) than external replacement in all 12 technology, labor market, and climate combinations while avoiding layoffs. External replacement achieved the highest skill fit but laid off 19% to 83% of incumbents, eroded trust, and performed worst in tight labor markets. The hybrid strategy was best under the fastest change, and a partnership climate raised NPV under all strategies. Conclusions: The future of employment relations depends on whether organizations treat reskilling as a joint investment governed by trust and social dialogue. Limitations: The parameters are illustrative, so the results are simulation based and should be validated with organizational data. Contributions: The study integrates strategic human capital theory and employment relations research in a dynamic model and offers propositions and guidance for managers, employee representatives, and policy makers.
Institution: Southern Delta University, Ozoro
Language: English
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234358744
