Work

Post-traumatic victimhood - attributing hostility to the benevolent others

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The article presents a unique aspect of hostility attribution in posttraumatic victimhood states, conceptualizing them as a fixation within the process of trauma recovery. While acknowledging the reality of traumatic suffering, the paper argues that partial recovery from trauma may paradoxically facilitate the emergence of a stable victimhood self-state. As dissociated emotions of humiliation, rage, and revenge become reactivated within safer interpersonal environments, aggression that could not be directed toward the original perpetrator is displaced onto benevolent and emotionally significant others. This displacement is expressed through accusations, complaints, demands for compensation, and the attribution of hostility to those who are caring and supportive. Drawing on the object relations theorists and relational psychoanalysis, the paper conceptualizes these processes through projective identification and containment. A detailed clinical case illustrates how complementary identification enables the therapist to recognize both the patient’s authentic suffering and the unacknowledged suffering of those around the patient. Therapeutic emphasis is placed on empathy, witnessing, containment, and the gradual reintroduction of the reality and subjectivity of the other. The paper concludes by suggesting that persistent post-traumatic victimhood may represent not only a post-traumatic condition but also a stable personality configuration that deserves further theoretical, clinical, and empirical investigation.
Author: Avi Berman
Institution: Tel Aviv University
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234408414
FWCI:
Cites: 18
Cited by:
Related to: 10