Work

Paper 4 — predeclared plan v1.0: what makes a model or a prior good or bad for a difference in arithmetic means? (Behrens–Fisher programme)

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Prospective registration of the predeclared plan (v1.0, frozen 16 Nov 2026) for Paper 4 in a programme on the direction of small-sample interval failure for a difference in arithmetic means. Paper 4 asks what makes a model or an informative prior good or bad for that difference. On the model side it tests whether the bias of a misspecified family's pseudo-true mean predicts the one-sided error of its posterior interval and its growth with sample size, whether mean-preserving families (gamma, inverse Gaussian) are safe on direction, whether a shape-preserving sandwich calibration repairs coverage, and whether a mean-gap diagnostic guard works. On the prior side, on a registered subset of 18 settings, it tests how shape priors and priors on the difference pull the interval as a function of prior effective sample size and centring error, whether heavy-tailed and robust-mixture priors limit the damage, and what double use of the data does. The design has 156 settings of positive-valued populations new to the programme (13 group pairings, 6 sample-size pairs, 2 mean differences). Hypotheses M1–M4, P1–P4, N1 and R1 are stated with criteria. The package contains the frozen plan (with a typeset PDF copy) and its SHA-256 fingerprint, all code including the frozen confirmatory analysis, the frozen pseudo-true quantities, grid-accuracy and leave-one-out validations, and the Monte Carlo endpoint check that set the draw counts and served as the pilot, all on non-study seeds. No Paper 4 computation on study data had been run at the time of deposit. AI-use note (paste, or use the programme's final wording): The plan, code and checks were developed with Claude (Anthropic) as a computational assistant under the author's direction; the author approved the design decisions and hypotheses and is responsible for the registration.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234451288
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10