Work

Distinguishing Robustness from Validity in AHP-Based Industrial Cluster Selection for Thailand’s Bio-Circular-Green Economic Corridor

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Industrial cluster selection commits a region’s resources and its environmental trajectory for a decade or more, so the credibility of the methods that settle it matters. This study re-analyses a completed analytic hierarchy process prioritisation of four candidate clusters for Thailand’s Northern Economic Corridor, in which a three-constituency panel’s judgements were combined by aggregating individual priorities. In a main suite of 45,000 stochastic replications and 24 deterministic scenarios, the two leading clusters are never displaced, and a stronger supplementary perturbation exchanges them in only 2 of 10,000 replications; the order of the last two depends on how the panellists are weighted. The project’s documentary record, coded by two authors and an external coder, registers structural considerations that no perturbation can reach. Robustness and validity therefore come apart: the suite is most certain about the leading positions, yet the record questions the set of alternatives from which they were drawn, and treating environmental performance as a condition rather than a weighted criterion changes which clusters are selected. From this single retrospective case, the paper proposes a four-check diagnostic for the terms of reference of a selection exercise, where considerations bearing on SDGs 9, 12 and 13 are most easily lost.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,896
OpenAlex ID: W7234471564
FWCI:
Cites: 42
Cited by:
Related to: 10