D is for deposit: extending Europe’s carbon storage obligation to account for all hydrocarbons
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The European Union has made carbon capture and storage a legal objective, but who pays to unlock geological storage, and on what terms, remains open. Article 23 of the Net-Zero Industry Act obliges only the domestic EU oil and gas producers, while most oil and gas reaches the Single Market with no storage duty. We propose a storage deposit made at first sale of oil and gas, by domestic and imported supply alike, at one rate. It is redeemed only against injected tonnes of CO₂, each counted once whatever its origin; deposits not redeemed within three years forfeit to a ring-fenced fund for transport and storage infrastructure. The rate is set at T&S cost and capped at one stored tonne per tonne sold, beyond which policy for carbon dioxide removal takes over. We size the deposit for three volume scenarios and two storage pathways. Under the European Commission’s pathway, €268bn is paid in over 2030–2050 at €72/tCO₂; most is returned on redemption, and about 10% forfeits if storage runs five years late. The deposit adds €5–17 to a barrel of oil in 2040 and reaches the cap before 2050 in three of six scenario combinations. Tested against six conditions (verification, redemption, ring-fence, coverage, handover, and legal basis), it meets the five design conditions, most with a stated concession, and its legal route is plausible. Extending the take-back logic of Article 23 to every seller would let the EU set the terms of access to its hydrocarbon market.
DOI: 10.31223/x5hr6x
Institution: University of Edinburgh
Language: English
Topic: Energy Law and Policy
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234482859
