Work

Applying the Grammar of Conceptual Moves: Diagnostic Moves, Teaching, and a Consolidated Inventory

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: A previous article proposed a grammar of conceptual moves: operations that change a conceptual map by drawing or removing boundaries, introducing degrees, arranging levels, reshaping relations, or changing what kind of thing a concept denotes. This companion article extends that grammar in three directions. First, it explicates the diagnostic moves, which the earlier article only named. They are treated as procedures for parsing a text rather than building one, each targeting a characteristic failure of a constructive move. Examples include detecting non-comparability, detecting a field’s equivocation, detecting question substitution, and immanent critique. Second, it adds moves the earlier article did not cover and places each under that article’s headings. These include showing incompatibility or compatibility, weighting, widening the system boundary, bracketing a question, typology to topology, recognizing transdomain structure, and marking the limits of a metaphor. Third, it proposes how the grammar can be taught, from recognition through production and evaluation to diagnosis, with four exercises and suggested answers. A consolidated inventory lists every move named in the two articles. The aim is structural reading: the capacity to see what a text does to its concepts, so that the moves on which scholarship depends can be learned, made, and judged deliberately.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234489135
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10