Work

Which Auckland Junctions Have More Fatal or Serious-Injury Crashes Later? Comparing Historical Crash Rankings

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Objective. Ranking junctions by fatal and serious-injury (DSI) crashes in the last five years is a simple way to pick safety sites, but the counts are noisy and unlucky sites tend to look better later. This study tests that rule, as a benchmark rather than any agency's procedure, against all-injury lists. Data. Public NZ Transport Agency crash records and OpenStreetMap junctions: 21,789 Auckland junctions within 500 m of a 2006 to 2019 injury crash, ranked on 2015 to 2019 and tested on 2022 to 2025. Outcomes are crashes, not people. Tests were pre-registered, including the 1,000-junction primary list size, set on 9 November 2026 by a power rule before any test-year junction outcome was opened (originally 310, and 85 before that). Findings. At 1,000 junctions, an all-injury list with empirical-Bayes smoothing and a predicted DSI share caught 285 later DSI crashes against 192: ratio 1.484 (95% interval 1.257 to 1.705). At 310 it is inconclusive: 1.089 (0.914 to 1.366). Exploratory checks suggest most of the gain comes from using all injury crashes (plain all-injury count: 1.359) and from the DSI rule filling its list with single-DSI sites; the extra modelling (not separated here) adds little. The 310 top-DSI junctions held 36.3% of junction DSI crashes in 2015 to 2019 but 10.4% in 2022 to 2025, mixing regression to the mean with any safety work. What is new. No earlier held-out test of these rankings on urban junctions was found (search not verified as complete). Practical use. For analysts shortlisting about 1,000 junctions from crash counts alone, results favour all injury crashes over DSI alone; at about 310, there is no evidence either way.
Author: Ling, Jayden
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234499583
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10