Digital Sanctions Law: A Proportionality-Based Architecture for Escalating Remedies in Repeated Online Misconduct
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This article proposes Digital Sanctions Law as an analytical subfield concerned with the design, sequencing and review of sanctions for legally established digital misconduct. Instead of treating account suspension as either a trivial platform choice or a substitute for criminal punishment, it develops a five-factor proportionality matrix: legal severity, culpability, recurrence, actual or foreseeable harm, and the availability of less restrictive remedies. Existing points of comparison include Article 23 of the EU Digital Services Act, EU penalty architecture, the United Kingdom Online Safety Act and Australia’s online abuse mechanisms. The article distinguishes public fines from private platform sanctions, temporary risk controls from final determinations, and restorative interventions from detention. It proposes income-sensitive natural-person fines, turnover-sensitive corporate penalties and narrowly defined criminal liability where a legislature separately creates an offence. Two worked hypothetical cases illustrate the prohibition against mechanical escalation. Model provisions require notice, reasons, evidence, judicial control, reversible interim measures, sunset periods and systematic review. The thesis is normative: predictability and deterrence should not be pursued at the expense of lawful expression, equality, the presumption of innocence or access to remedy.
Author: yıldırım, Begüm
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234508513
