Performance of Dental House Officers at a Single Training Institute in Karachi: A Retrospective Descriptive Analysis of Clinical Assessment, Continuing Professional Development, and Academic Output
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Background: The one-year house job (compulsory rotating internship) is the final supervised stage of dental training in Pakistan before independent registration. Institutional evaluation records are a routine source of information on house-officer performance, but little has been published on how these records are composed or how points are distributed across their domains. Objective: To describe the year-end evaluation record of one cohort of dental house officers at a single training institute in Karachi. Methods: Retrospective, descriptive, cross-sectional record review of all eligible house officers who completed the one-year programme at private dental institute, Karachi in 2025-2026 and had a complete evaluation record (n = 19 of 23 enrolled). No sample size calculation was performed because the whole eligible cohort was included. Descriptive statistics, 95% confidence intervals, each domain’s share of total points and exploratory Pearson correlations were computed Results: The mean composite score was 411.93 ± 52.11 (95% CI 386.8–437.0), i.e. 74.2% ± 9.4% of the maximum attainable 555.5 (range 299.30–471.68). The assessment score (mean 400.16 ± 51.36) contributed 97.1% of mean total points and CPD 2.8%; the four scholarly domains together contributed 0.04%, because each was recorded on a 0–0.10 scale. Conclusion: In this single-institution record, total scores were determined almost entirely by assessment marks because of how the composite is scored, not necessarily because house officers differed little in other domains. The findings describe one cohort and cannot be generalised to house officers in Karachi or Pakistan.
DOI: 10.69491/187w1b38
Authors: Dr. Aimen Zahid, Dr Mahnoor Zahid
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234513661
