Work

HEUSTOC: A Heuristic-Stochastic Theory of Human Choice Under Uncertainty

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper puts forward a simple idea in plain language, and then defends it carefully. When people have to decide under uncertainty - when they do not have full information, enough time, or a clear way to calculate the best option - they do not sit and calculate like a machine. They use shortcuts. A shortcut here means a short, practical rule that has worked before, or that other people around them use, or that fits the story they tell themselves about what is happening. Examples are: do what worked last time, do what most people are doing, avoid the worst loss first, trust the person who seems experienced, wait a little longer, or pick the option that makes the story make sense. At the same time, people do not just apply one shortcut and stop. They keep watching what happens. They get new information. Some of that information is clear. Much of it is noisy, confusing, incomplete, or misleading. They update what they believe, a little at a time. Sometimes the update is small. Sometimes a surprise makes them drop the old shortcut and try a new one. Choice, in this view, is not a single moment of calculation. Choice is a pause in an ongoing process of updating, a moment when a person must act even though updating is not finished. This paper calls this combined process HEUSTOC. The first part of the word points to shortcuts. The second part points to the fact that updating always involves chance, noise, and incomplete information. The theory has four linked claims. First, new options and new shortcuts are constantly being generated, by accident, by imitation, by experiment, and by misunderstanding. Second, most of those options and shortcuts are eliminated, because they fail, because they are forgotten, because they do not fit the situation, or because a better shortcut replaces them. Third, what remains is not the best or the most perfect option. What remains is the option that is robust enough to survive - the option that keeps working well enough, even when conditions change a little. To these three claims, this paper adds a… Fourth claim, which is central to the theory and is stated here as a definitive point: failures are not to be discarded. Some failures - often a small number of large, memorable, costly failures - play as much an important role, if not more, than the cumulative effect of all the minor successes put together. A minor success teaches a person: this shortcut worked this time, keep using it. A major failure teaches something different and deeper: this shortcut is dangerous here, this sieve is wrong, this story is false, this whole way of seeing the problem must change. Minor successes refine a shortcut. Major failures can replace the sieve itself. A society that remembers only its successes will keep refining the same shortcuts. A society that remembers its failures, studies them, and keeps them in its story, can change its shortcuts, change its filter, and sometimes change its direction. The theory is also useful in practice. First, it offers a new way to read human history and culture — not just as a list of successes, but as a record of shortcuts tried, failures kept or discarded, and filters changed over time. Second, it offers a new way to study decisions in everyday life — in homes, schools, clinics, markets, and organisations - by following people over time rather than judging a single choice. Third, it offers a more human way to design systems that learn alongside people, including digital and AI systems - systems that do not assume people are perfect calculators, but that respect how people actually update, hesitate, reverse, and learn from failure. The paper is written for a reader who may not have a background in economics, psychology, or statistics. Where a technical word is used, it is explained at once. The aim is that a reader whose first language is not English, and a reader who has never studied decision theory, can both follow the argument from start to finish.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234558146
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10