Work

Validity, Judgment, and Authority: The Hypotension Prediction Index as a Test Case for Clinical AI Alignment

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The Hypotension Prediction Index (HPI) estimates from the arterial waveform the likelihood of impending hypotension and, when the index is high, prompts review of a secondary screen that displays pulse pressure or stroke volume variation (PPV/SVV), peripheral arterial dP/dt, and dynamic arterial elastance (Eadyn) under the headings preload, contractility, and afterload. Its predictive performance is supported by meta-analyses, but the physiological meaning of the secondary-screen variables depends on conditions that the monitor does not verify, so that a numerically correct value can be physiologically uninterpretable. This narrative review summarizes the evidence on the prediction and on the validity conditions of each variable, using a companion conceptual framework that distinguishes the capability to evaluate from the authority to act. We separate the documented functions of the current software from extensions that we propose: a runtime validity gate that would verify, flag, or withhold interpretations whose prerequisites cannot be established, and a bedside sequence for clinicians. The framework, the proposed PPV checklist, and the taxonomy tables are expert-derived, have not been tested against clinical outcomes or usability data, and concern a single manufacturer's product. Within these limits, HPI illustrates a principle that we propose for clinical AI: prediction accuracy does not guarantee interpretation validity, and interpretation validity does not confer therapeutic authority.
Language: English
Subfield: Surgery
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234572306
FWCI:
Cites: 28
Cited by:
Related to: 10