Work

Crystal Polymorphs and Observability as a Persistence Filter: Separating Formation from Survival in the Inorganic Structural Record

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Crystal structure prediction returns hundreds or thousands of nearly degenerate candidate structures per composition, yet experiment records only a few polymorphs. The usual explanation is energetic: the observed forms are those closest to the energy minimum. This paper instead treats observability as a filter. A structure enters the record only if it is formed and then survives until it is observed. Thermally activated survival works as a sharp, Gumbel-shaped filter in the escape barrier. Its threshold is E* = k_BT ln(ν t_obs), and it moves by only k_BT per e-fold of observation time. From a single observed population and its energies alone, formation and survival cannot be told apart; this is the crystallographic instance of the Retrospective Drift Theorem. Under a Bell–Evans–Polanyi coupling, survival alone produces what looks like a thermodynamic ceiling on metastability. The empirical part uses open data: 154,387 Materials Project entries (via OPTIMADE), ICSD tags from JARVIS-DFT, and Crystallography Open Database metadata on pressure, temperature and mineral names, giving 10,583 metastable polymorphs in 5,417 compositions. The fraction of computed polymorphs that are observed is non-monotonic in energy, which rules out energy ranking as the selection rule. The sign structure of the record follows remnant metastability, and a coordination-based barrier proxy fails. Two tests diverge from formation-only explanations: Among phases documented above 1 GPa, retention at ambient conditions falls with energy (ρ = −0.29, p = 0.005). Natural minerals are less metastable than synthetic-only polymorphs (median 18.2 vs 30.0 meV/atom, p = 2.6×10⁻⁴). The record is therefore formation times persistence. The full analysis code is included in the appendix. Keywords: polymorphism; crystal structure prediction; overprediction; metastability; remnant metastability; Ostwald’s rule of stages; disappearing polymorphs; observation selection; persistence conditioning; retrospective drift; Materials Project; Crystallography Open Database Related identifiers: Is supplement to / References — https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.26532.64648 (The Retrospective Drift Theorem) Creator: Kriger, Boris — Information Physics Institute; Institute of Integrative and Interdisciplinary Research — ORCID 0009-0001-0034-2903 License: CC BY 4.0
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234615382
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10