Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Online discussions can keep growing while the range of evaluations they express contracts. We study this tunnel vision, the progressive concentration of a discussion on a smaller set of aspect-sentiment positions, and ask whether narrowing is transient or lasting and whether receding positions return. We develop a framework that links frozen, thread-specific aspect schemas and aspect-conditioned sentiment labels to whole-thread diversity trends, local contraction episodes and the identities of the positions expressed, and apply it to 2,967 event-centred Reddit threads from April 2019 drawn from a processed corpus of 6,128 threads. Observed tunnel vision occurs in 45.9% of threads, but only 9.3% narrow more than expected under a null that preserves labelled mention density. Local contractions are common (73.8% of threads) and usually reversible (83.7% of first episodes recover), whereas this density-robust minority recovers less often (60.9% versus 86.6%) and, after recovering, more often contracts again. Onset-aligned trajectories show that the groups diverge after onset rather than in their initial decline. Recovery brings back previously expressed positions and a more even distribution among continued positions, with small changes in first-observed pairs. Richer openings are associated with higher final diversity despite slightly steeper subsequent declines, separating relative narrowing from a narrow endpoint. An independent April 2018 sample reproduces these patterns. The results establish recovery as a central dimension of conversational diversity and provide empirical targets for explaining how online discussions sustain evaluative breadth.
Source: Research Square
Language: English
Subfield: Artificial Intelligence
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: online discourse, tunnel vision, opinion dynamics
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234632958
