The Asch Conformity Problem: From Domestic Pressure to Cognitive Passivity and Its Implications for Students’ Autonomous Thinking
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: High levels of social conformity among university students often hinder independent decision-making and critical thinking. While classic social psychology frames conformity primarily as a peer-group dynamic as demonstrated in Solomon Asch’s seminal experiments. This study investigates the manifestation of conformity among undergraduate students across three major universities in Indonesia and traces its psychosocial roots. A qualitative approach was employed, combining semi-structured in-depth interviews (N=36) and direct participant observation in academic and socio-cultural campus settings. The findings reveal a distinct trajectory of conformity: systemic psychological pressure and authoritarian parenting within the internal family environment establish a baseline of compliance long before students encounter peer groups. When transitioning to higher education, this internalized pressure manifests as acute self-doubt, anxiety over social divergence, and defensive alignment with majority opinions. Contrary to traditional models that view peer pressure as the primary driver of conformity, this study demonstrates that academic conformity is an amplified continuation of domestic psychological conditioning. Framed through the philosophy of education, this developmental dynamic systematically degrades critical thinking skills and undermines epistemic autonomy, rendering students passive recipients of collective consensus rather than independent analytical thinkers. The collected data were analyzed using thematic analysis following the Miles, Huberman, and Saldaña model. Practically, these findings urge higher education institutions to design learning spaces that guarantee epistemic safety and legitimize intellectual dissent to foster students' cognitive autonomy.
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7234687688
