Time Inconsistency and the Problem of Personal Identity under Existential Risk: A Modernized Version of the "Tithonus Curse" Thought Experiment
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper examines a modified version of the "Tithonus curse" thought experiment, adapted to contemporary biotechnological progress and the formal framework of rational choice theory. The classical dilemma of choosing between instant death and immortality under conditions of irreversible biological aging is re-evaluated by introducing a variable for the exponential growth of regenerative medicine and the concept of "longevity escape velocity." It is shown that this modification transforms an existential impasse into a problem of stochastic optimization planning and institutional risk hedging. However, a formal analysis of the expected utility function—accounting for the degeneration of the time-discounting factor during dementia and Derek Parfit’s psychological connectedness coefficient—reveals two fundamental barriers: the subject's vulnerability to an inverted "Pascal's mugging" amidst macrohistorical disruptions, and the ontological rupture of personal identity. We conclude that a rational resolution of the dilemma in favor of life extension is impossible within an egoistic decision theory framework.
Author: Tyutenkov, Deniel
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234731463
