A Null Citation Gap Is Not a Missing Reward: What Field-Level Comparisons of Papers With and Without Shared Data and Code Certify About the Incentive to Share, Why a Transportation Null and an Astrophysics Advantage Can Both Hold, and the Design That Would Price the Return
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: (c) 2026 Pranay Mahendrakar. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Life of Research Whether sharing data and code earns authors more citations is now contested in print. A 2026 study that used a large language model to label 10,724 transportation papers reports no citation difference for either practice and concludes that authors lack a direct incentive, while studies of PLOS, French and astrophysics corpora report data-sharing advantages of 4 to 32 percent and disagree about code. In this analysis the author reviews and synthesises published results to show that these findings answer different questions. The author separates four quantities reported as one "citation advantage": a cross-sectional association, the causal return to an author who shares, the effect of a journal policy, and the return that runs through reuse, each indexed by a citation window. From the transportation study's own agreement tables, the author reconstructs the classifier's confusion counts and derives attenuation factors of about 0.60 to 0.66 for the data-repository label and 0.71 to 0.99 for the code label. Its interval for papers that both cite data and link a repository therefore cannot exclude the published data advantages, while its interval for a repository without a data citation excludes the two largest, near 25 and 32 percent, even after that correction, and is compatible only with the smaller ones; its code interval excludes the published code advantages, but comes from a specification whose listed controls omit publication year, in a corpus where code-sharing papers are younger. Quasi-experimental evidence on the incentive is thin and split, and the only randomised trials, on open access, found no citation advantage. The paper consolidates 24 published estimates in one table, states a procedure for reading a null of this kind, and proposes a validation-corrected, window-indexed design that would price the return to sharing within a single field.
Author: Mahendrakar, Pranay
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234756650
