Work

Recognising Need: Social Assistance, Gender and Food Ethics in Albania during COVID-19

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: During the COVID−19 pandemic, many governments protected access to food by expanding existing cash social-assistance schemes rather than distributing food. Ethical assessments of such assistance have focused mainly on targeting methods, and much less on how schemes define need in the first place, particularly the needs of women carrying unpaid care. This article addresses that gap. It argues that crisis responses inherit the definitions of need built into the schemes they extend, a dynamic termed inherited recognition, so that the fairness of emergency food assistance is largely settled before the emergency. To examine this, the article develops a Recognition-to-Access framework with four stages: recognition of need, translation into eligibility rules, practical access, and ethical assessment. Through a qualitative documentary analysis of 24 coded records, comprising provisions of Albania’s 2019 social assistance law, implementing decisions and 2020 crisis measures, and findings from institutional assessments, the framework is applied to Albania’s economic assistance scheme. Albania doubled payments quickly and paid them to women, yet extra support reached almost only families already in the scheme. The law sanctions families whose working-age members do not register as jobseekers and allows no exception for unpaid care, which fell largely on women during lockdown, while food in kind was left mostly to charity. Drawing on care ethics and the right to adequate food, I contend that this rule cannot be justified without a care exemption. The article contributes a concept, a transferable analytical framework and stage-specific reforms for future crisis assistance.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234757547
Cites: 15
Cited by:
Related to: 10