Three Chick (Gallus gallus) Breeds Differing in Domestication and Selection Status Show Proto-Arithmetic Abilities in Distinguishing Empty from Non-Empty Sets
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Tracking the quantity of moving objects is advantageous in natural environments. Animals can monitor prey, predators, conspecifics, offspring, and other relevant items. For domesticated animals in captivity, the evolutionary pressure on this ability has likely changed. Here, we compare three breeds of day-old chicks differing in domestication status and selection for productivity (Ross308, Gallina Padovana, Red Junglefowl) in a task that required successive addition and subtraction of objects. Chicks (n=48) were reared with five identical objects, which they treated as artificial social companions, naturally preferring the larger group. At test, chicks watched objects disappearing one-by-one behind two opaque screens. Subsequently, some objects were moved between screens, requiring chicks to add and subtract to locate the larger group. We assessed whether chicks can handle empty sets as the result of addition and subtraction. We found no evidence of breed differences, although the study was not powered to detect small differences. Ross308 and Gallina Padovana, but not Red Junglefowl (p=0.054), chicks chose the larger group in the 0 vs .5 comparison (resulting from either 2 -2 vs . 3 +2 or 3 -3 vs . 2 +3 ); but not in 2 vs .3 (resulting from either 4 -1 vs . 1 +1 or 4 -2 vs . 1 +2 ). In a follow-up experiment, chicks of the most productive breed (n=15) performed significantly above chance level also with the final comparison 0 vs .3, showing that successful empty-set discrimination is not limited to large numerical contrasts. These results suggest that proto-arithmetic abilities involving empty sets are present in breeds that differ markedly in domestication and selection for productivity.
Source: Research Square
Institution: University of Padua
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Zero hunger
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234855213
