Work

Proportionality and the Surveillance State: Testing the State Exemptions in the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 Against the Puttaswamy Standard

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 is India’s first comprehensive statute on the processing of digital personal data, enacted in response to the Supreme Court’s recognition of privacy as a fundamental right in 2017. This paper examines whether the provisions of the Act that favour the State, namely its exemption for notified instrumentalities, its non-consensual “legitimate use” ground, its power to call for information, and the accompanying amendment to the Right to Information Act, 2005, satisfy the proportionality standard that the Court laid down for restrictions on privacy. The study is doctrinal and comparative. It reconstructs the constitutional standard from the Court’s privacy and Aadhaar decisions, applies its components of legality, legitimate aim, necessity and procedural safeguards to the statutory text, and draws on European and American authority to test its conclusions. The paper argues that the aims pursued are constitutionally acceptable, but that the Act fails the tests of necessity and procedural safeguards. It disapplies the entire statute by executive notification, retains no baseline security or accountability duties for exempted bodies, provides no independent prior authorisation or post-facto notice, and entrusts oversight to a Board whose members are appointed by the executive. The paper concludes that these defects are architectural rather than incidental, and proposes statutory reforms, including tailored exemptions, an express necessity standard, independent authorisation, transparency reporting and a restored public-interest override, together with an interpretive route open to the courts.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234867215
FWCI:
Cites: 6
Cited by:
Related to: 10