A Comparative Analysis of Three Quantitative Pricing Frameworks for SSE 50ETF Options: BS Analytical Model, CRR Binomial Tree Model and Monte Carlo Simulation
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study compares the effectiveness and feasibility of the Black-Scholes (BS) analytical model, the Cox-Ross-Rubinstein (CRR) binomial-tree model and Monte Carlo simulation of SSE 50 ETF European call contracts. With the help of the no-arbitrage condition, risk-neutral valuation and geometric Brownian motion are used to create these three models in Python with the same benchmark parameters and later compare their pricing accuracy, convergence rate and algorithmic efficiency, and their applicability to various applications. The numerical data shows that the three methods give almost the same option price: 0.0846 to the BS model, 0.0847 the 200-step CRR model, and 0.0843 the Monte Carlo simulation of 100, 000 paths. The BS approach is by nature simple and easy to use, but has some limitations. As the number of iterations increases, the CRR framework is inclined to the BS value and thus can be used in American style options. High-dimensional and path-dependent derivatives are best modeled using Monte Carlo simulation, whose accuracy depends on the number of simulated paths and the traditional model is not able to price American contracts directly. These results explain the tradeoff between accuracy, flexibility and computational cost in option pricing model selection.
Author: Xiaoyu Lin
Institution: Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University
Language: English
Subfield: Finance
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7234868316
