Regulatory gaps in transport aircraft crashworthiness: a comparative assessment of Nig.CARs Part 25, 14 CFR Part 25 and CS-25 using accident case studies
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Many transport aircraft accidents are survivable, so the regulations governing structural crashworthiness largely determine occupant outcomes. The Nigerian Civil Aviation Regulations (Nig.CARs) Part 25 draw on 14 CFR Part 25 and EASA CS-25, but their alignment with those standards, and their adequacy against real accident evidence, have not been evaluated. This study combines a provision-level comparison of the three frameworks with a compliance assessment of five accident case studies (two investigated by the Nigerian Accident Investigation Bureau, three by foreign authorities) across four domains: fuselage and floor integrity, seat and restraint performance, fuel system and fire protection, and cabin interior and evacuation. Each domain outcome was coded compliant, non-compliant, partial or inconclusive, or out of scope, and the non-compliant and out-of-scope outcomes were consolidated into a register of regulatory gaps. Nig.CARs Part 25 was substantially aligned with the two reference frameworks in three of the four domains, but did not explicitly adopt the fuel system component provisions of 14 CFR 25.994. Non-compliant outcomes occurred in 11 of 20 case-domain assessments and in every domain, most often in cabin interior and evacuation (four of five cases). Seat structural failures occurred in two independent accidents under loading not represented by the certification test pulses, and one high-energy accident fell outside the design envelope. Six gaps, all rated of high safety significance, were identified, and five improvement proposals are made, the most urgent being full adoption of the 25.994 equivalent in Nig.CARs. The findings are qualitative, rest on five purposively selected cases, and are best read as hypotheses for further testing.
Institution: University of Ibadan
Language: English
Subfield: Automotive Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234882977
