Understanding therapeutic collaboration: triangulation of client, therapist, and observer perspectives
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Therapeutic collaboration is a central relational process linked to positive outcomes in psychotherapy. Although research has examined this process either through external observation or through participants' perspectives, it has rarely examined both. This study addressed that gap by triangulating three perspectives - client, therapist, and an independent observer using the Therapeutic Collaboration Coding System (TCCS) – to explore collaborative and non-collaborative moments in early therapy sessions. A comparative multiple-case study design was employed with three therapeutic dyads that differed in therapists’ clinical experience and prior training in the TCCS. Data comprised session recordings, a purpose-built questionnaire, and video-assisted recall interviews with therapists and clients. Findings showed strong alignment between client experience and observer coding across all dyads, supporting the coding system’s sensitivity to clients’ moment-to-moment experiences of safety or tensions within the therapeutic relationship. Alignment between therapist and observer perspectives varied with clinical experience and training, with greater convergence found among more experienced or trained therapists. Divergences proved theoretically informative, pointing to communicative differences with a neurodivergent client and to moments where therapists held simultaneously supportive and challenging intentions that the coding system could not fully capture. These results support using the coding system not only as a research tool but as a resource for training and supervision, helping therapists develop explicit awareness of the relational function of their interventions and refine responsiveness to clients whose engagement may not follow conventional markers.
Source: Research Square
Institution: University of Minho
Language: English
Subfield: Clinical Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234904790
