Work

When Is Non-Action a Choice? Negative Evidence, Deferred Projects, and the Attribution of Choice

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Sociological explanations often interpret unchanged conduct as either a decision to continue or continuation without choice. The same non-event can also result from intentional abstention or an adopted project whose execution has been deferred. This article develops a framework for assessing these attributions. It draws on interpretive action theory and process-tracing methodology. It connects the act and period under examination, the actor's relation to an alternative, and the institutional production of evidence. Four configurations organize the analysis without forming an exhaustive or mutually exclusive classification. The deferred project identifies an undertaking that remains intended beyond its anticipated occasion of execution. Missing evidence favors one configuration over another when the relevant trace would have been more likely under the alternative being weighed. Institutional response requirements and defaults affect this comparison: they can make similar conduct differently visible without any difference in deliberation. Three premises and three propositions state the framework, the last developing conditional expectations about the effects of making alternatives salient and supporting the execution of existing projects. Educational non-participation provides the main application, and a published comparison of default and active-decision pension enrollment provides a worked case. Theories of choice and habit therefore need an account of how their proposed mechanisms become observable. Without one, institutional differences can be mistaken for differences in actors' relations to alternatives.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234907977
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10