Vocal and instrumental specialization in verbal and visuospatial memory: a two-dataset analysis
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Introduction Vocal and instrumental activities combine articulation, notation, and spatially organized action in distinct ways. Comparing verbal and visuospatial memory can clarify whether musical specialization is linked to a specific memory domain. Methods We conducted secondary, cross-sectional analyses of two independent public datasets. Study 1 compared 96 vocalists and 540 instrumentalists from Music Ensemble across 35 sites in 16 countries. The primary dependent variable was standardized Digit Span minus standardized Spatial Span. Study 2 compared 39 amateur vocalists and 43 amateur instrumentalists aged 20–88 years from PICCOLO on auditory Digit Span. Study 2 examined verbal memory in a separate participant sample; it did not assess visuospatial memory or the verbal-minus-visuospatial profile. Results After adjusting for demographics, training, socioeconomic status, and site, the Study 1 vocalist-minus-instrumentalist profile coefficient was 0.417 (95% CI [0.152, 0.682], p = 0.002) in standardized-component contrast units. Separate task models indicated higher Spatial Span performance among instrumentalists: the vocalist-minus-instrumentalist coefficient was −0.368 SD (95% CI [−0.578, −0.158]). Digit Span showed no statistically detectable group difference (0.049 SD, 95% CI [−0.197, 0.294]). Additional education/practice adjustment yielded a profile coefficient of 0.419; the mixed-activity subset yielded 0.184 (95% CI [−0.147, 0.514]). In Study 2, adjusted group differences were not statistically detectable for forward recall (0.027 SD, 95% CI [−0.526, 0.580]), backward recall (0.186 SD, 95% CI [−0.338, 0.711]), or their total (0.131 SD, 95% CI [−0.380, 0.642]). An exploratory synthesis of the verbal-memory coefficients yielded 0.064 SD (95% CI [−0.157, 0.286]; total N = 718). Post-hoc equivalence testing supported ±0.30-SD but not ±0.20-SD bounds; Bayesian support for the point null was modest and prior-dependent ( BF 01 = 2.46). Discussion The clearest specialization-related difference was higher visuospatial recall among instrumentalists than among vocalists in Study 1, whereas neither study detected a verbal-memory advantage among vocalists. These findings distinguish relative memory profiles from task performance and characterize cognitive associations related to musical specialization and training history.
Source: Frontiers in Psychology
Institution: Chuzhou University
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,801
OpenAlex ID: W7234930716
