Work

Scoring cell types by RNA content: a reusable audit framework and its application to single-cell lactylation claims

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Ranking cell types by a gene-set score is routine, and the order is often read as biology, though the procedure assumes the set carries information beyond a cell's RNA content. We built an audit framework–housekeeping substitution, an expression-matched permutation null, residualisation against technical covariates and a positive-control arm and applied it to lactylation scoring in 16 public single-cell datasets (113,419 cells) and to three non-metabolic signatures (hypoxia, stemness, senescence), two failing the same controls. A 40-gene housekeeping panel matched or beat the 100-114-gene set in 8 of 15, expression-matched random sets in 10 of 15, and none survived Benjamini-Hochberg correction (minimum q = 0.106). Within-cell coupling to detected-gene count was positive in all 15 (median +0.574). The cross-cell-type collinearity statistic proved untestable: +0.991 in simulation with no signal. Its residualised variant is demoted to a span-gated diagnostic, readable only where detection rate spans 0.15, and non-monotonic. Under two established implementations coupling fell by a median of 60%, never vanishing, and the top-ranked type agreed in only 7 of 13 datasets. Coupling also operates within a cell type: the score is higher in the deeper half in 114 of 116 comparisons, and depth-matching leaves the score-to-depth effect ratio flat at 0.55. Hypoxia and stemness signatures of 28 genes fail the same control (median SSR 0.436 and 0.440), so this is not specific to metabolism; a senescence panel with genuine cell-type restriction passes (1.298). The lactylation set carries 1.67 times the gene-level variance of expression-matched sets; controlling for depth and variance together lowers median SSR from 0.825 to 0.363. Variance matching leaves the coupling intact (97.2% positive) whereas an analytic Pearson residual removes it (56.0%), locating the fault in the summed-score construction, not the normalisation. A lineage-marker positive control passed, so the limitation concerns the estimator, not lactylation biology.
Author: Jiadong Fu
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,120
OpenAlex ID: W7234934832
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10