Work

An Error in Callahan and Mankin’s Extreme-Heat Damage Formula

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Two widely cited studies by Christopher Callahan and Justin Mankin, in Science Advances (2022) and Nature (2025), estimate that human-caused extreme heat reduced global GDP by $33 trillion (1992–2013) and attribute $28 trillion in losses (1991–2020) to 111 fossil-fuel companies. Roger Pielke Jr. recently found that these results depend on the temperature scale used, with Callahan and Mankin’s 2025 code producing total losses of $28 trillion if run in Celsius, $43 trillion if run in Fahrenheit, and $359 trillion if run in Kelvin. Building on that finding, we identify the term in their damage formula that produces this anomaly. Their formula can be decomposed into three terms. Two of those terms measure the effect of added extreme heat on GDP, including the greater sensitivity to extreme heat in a warmer climate. The third term, which we call the zero-point term, multiplies that greater sensitivity by the full temperature reading of the heat wave that would have occurred without warming—implicitly counting every degree above 0 °C, so its size depends on where the temperature scale places zero rather than on how much extreme heat changed. As a result, this term attributes GDP losses to extreme heat even when extreme heat does not change, and it causes the damage formula to report losses even in regions where the model predicts that hotter heat waves increased growth across the entire warming range. Removing that term, and using the authors’ own code and data, reduces their extreme-heat losses by more than 90%, to $1.9 trillion (2022) and $2.5 trillion (2025), with uncertainty ranges that include net GDP gains.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234953579
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10