Who reports change? A PRISMA 2020 systematic review and stratified multi-informant meta-analysis of digital self-directed parenting programmes for children aged 2–12
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study designs: Systematic Review, Meta-Analysis
Abstract: Background: Self-directed digital parenting programmes are widely promoted for childhood disruptive behaviour, anxiety, and lifestyle risk, yet parents simultaneously receive the unmasked intervention and serve as primary proxy informants of child change. Pooling incompatible reporters obscures whether gains generalise beyond the participating caregiver. Methods: Under PRISMA 2020 guidelines, an archival register (8,047 records) and multi-database searches across OpenAlex, Crossref, Semantic Scholar, and Europe PMC/PubMed with Unpaywall resolution (2,493 records through 8 November 2026; 7,928 unique records screened) verified 144 full texts across 38 qualitative/audit cohorts and 27 unique RCT cohorts (28 non-overlapping contrasts; N = 10,157 randomised families; ages 2–12; 51 channel estimates). Subgroup A REML meta-analyses stratified six informant channels across superiority and active-comparator trials. Subgroup B synthesised within-trial paired contrasts (Δg = g_parent − g_second; 19 multi-informant cohorts, 22 pairs) across cross-reporter correlations (r = .20, .35, .50) and tested channel independence and denominator balance (N_second / N_parent). Results: In superiority RCTs (24 cohorts, 25 arms), unmasked parent ratings showed a robust benefit (k = 25, N = 7,412, g = +0.252, 95% CI [+0.187, +0.316], p = 1.84 × 10⁻¹⁴, I² = 54.7%), moderating from guided packages (g = +0.406) to purely self-directed programmes (k = 17, g = +0.211; Egger p = .0027; PEESE g = +0.143). Pooled independent non-parent channels yielded a null effect with zero heterogeneity (k = 12, N = 2,406 assessments across 11 cohorts [2,054 children], g = +0.023 [−0.051, +0.096], p = .545, I² = 0%): independent child self-report (k = 3, g = +0.037), teacher report (k = 2, g = −0.031), masked video observation (k = 3, g = +0.004), and wearable accelerometry/blinded anthropometry (k = 4, g = +0.014). Corroboration occurred only when secondary channels remained coupled to the unmasked parent via parent clinician interviews (k = 6, g = +0.419; pure self-directed k = 3, g = +0.212) or parent-forwarded child chat links (g = +0.401). Paired contrasts confirmed a superiority informant wedge (k = 11, Δg = +0.266 [+0.167, +0.364], p = 1.29 × 10⁻⁷ at r = .35; β₀ = +0.253 at N_S/N_P = 1.0; R² = 88.0%), reversing when staff delivery beat online self-help on parent ratings but not masked video (Δg = −0.414, p = .0028) or teacher ratings (Δg = −0.296, p = .024). Conclusions: Unmasked parent-reported child gains in self-directed digital programmes do not transfer to independent child, teacher, masked video, or sensor channels. Trials must separate informant channels, balance denominators, and report cross-reporter covariances.
Source: Research Square
Author: Alexander Kuznetsov
Language: English
Subfield: Applied Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234966190
