Criminal Liability for the Forgery of Authentic Deeds by Notaries in Cases of Failure of Local Government Oversight
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The forgery of authentic deeds by notaries is a serious issue in the Indonesian legal system because it has a direct impact on legal certainty, public trust, and the legitimacy of the state. The increasing number of criminal cases involving notaries indicates that this problem does not stem solely from individual errors but is also related to weak administrative oversight by local governments. Judicial practice tends to hold notaries solely responsible for criminal liability without considering the underlying structural factors. This study aims to analyze the construction of notaries’ criminal liability in the crime of forgery of authentic deeds and to examine the failure of local government oversight as a criminogenic factor, using the case study of the Balikpapan District Court Decision No. 296/Pid.B/2024. The method used is normative legal research employing legislative, conceptual, and case-based approaches through a literature review analyzed using a prescriptive qualitative approach. The results indicate that the criminal liability of notaries remains dominated by an individual liability approach that disregards failures in land administration oversight. This situation contributes to the criminalization of the notary’s office. This study recommends reconstructing the paradigm of criminal liability by reaffirming criminal law as the ultimum remedium and proposes a novel “integrated administrative-criminal oversight” model that positions local governments as the systemic custodians responsible for preventing document-based crimes.
Institution: Universitas Dr. Soetomo
Language: English
Topic: Legal Studies and Policies
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7234982725
