Sentencing imbalance and the absence of reference points: the crime of exam substitution in China
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: As China increasingly criminalizes minor wrongdoing, precise and proportionate sentencing has become a pressing concern, yet little empirical attention has been paid to micro-crimes that lack statutory reference points. The crime of taking an exam on behalf of another person is a case in point: it is punishable by criminal detention, public surveillance, or a fine but, unlike other exam-cheating offenses, provides for neither statutory sentencing circumstances nor an aggravated tier. Drawing on a nationwide sample of 1,882 defendants from the PKU Law database, this article combines regression models with multilevel variance decomposition across court levels. It finds that mitigating circumstances operate at the lenient end of sentencing—probation, a fine alone, or a shorter custodial term—and that sentencing imbalance is concentrated in basic-level courts, where the court level contributes the largest variance component (intraclass correlation coefficient ≈ 0.54, rising to 0.63 for probation). This micro-crime thus serves as a boundary case for the theory of jurisdictional uniformity, tracing the observed court-level imbalance to the absence of objective reference points.
Source: Research Square
Authors: Lifeng Li, Ting Song, Xue Xia, Xiaoye Li
Institutions: Jilin University, Northeast Normal University
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7234984568
