Work

Above Us and Still Ours: Granted Otherness and the Wish to Build a Superior Machine

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The people who build the most powerful artificial intelligence say publicly that it could destroy humanity, and they go on building it. This essay asks why. It argues that the usual explanations (benefit, the race, engineering) all rest on the same belief: that humans will remain in control. This belief behaves not like a bet that moves with the evidence but like an illusion in Freud’s sense, sustained by a wish. Drawing mainly on Winnicott, the essay identifies the wish for an Other who is above us and still ours, modeled on the earliest object of infancy. Humans have always held such an Other as a paradox, as they have held their gods. The danger begins when the paradox is to be built. Superiority granted while independence is withheld is granted otherness, and granted otherness is not otherness at all. Zapffe’s account of consciousness as a burden explains why the Other must be superior: it is to carry what we cannot. Bion’s basic assumptions explain how the fantasy is held in common, and why the builders’ warnings tend to keep the group inside it. The essay closes with the argument’s limits and with what would prove it wrong.
Author: Gross, Tobey
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235061512
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 9