Work

The Right to Be More Than a Record: Narrative Non-Exhaustion, Human Dignity, and the Ethics of Institutional Judgment

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Institutional records can be accurate yet insufficient to justify consequential judgments about a person’s character, credibility, or future capacity. This article asks when that gap amounts to wrongful institutional misrecognition rather than ordinary evidential uncertainty. Using a purposive critical-interpretive synthesis of narrative identity, recognition theory, epistemic injustice, classification studies, privacy, and reasoned administration, it develops the Principle of Narrative Non-Exhaustion (PNE). The principle holds that an institution must justify the inferential distance between a purpose-bounded record and the wider conclusion on which it acts. Its distinctive concern is inferential overreach, including implicit generalizations through repeated decisions, not mere record inaccuracy or the duration of an algorithmic label. A refined Narrative Non-Exhaustion Review differentiates consequentiality and generalization gateways and evaluates scope, warrant, voice, revisability, and proportionality. A hypothetical professional-safeguarding case involving proven misconduct, subsequent remediation, uncertain risk, and third-party safety demonstrates how a restrictive decision may remain justified without treating a historical finding as an immutable identity. The paper situates this proposal alongside administrative reasonableness, contextual integrity, procedural fairness, and temporal authorship, acknowledging substantial overlap rather than asserting a new positive-law right. Its contribution is an operationally precise specification of what reasoned, non-exhaustive institutional judgment demands, together with decision standards and limitations requiring future empirical testing.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7235140161
FWCI:
Cites: 14
Cited by:
Related to: 10