Work

Integrating Transformative and Existential Strategies into Trauma-Focused Psychotherapy: A Multi-Study Analysis of EMDR, 3MDR, and Psychedelic-Assisted Group Therapy

Year: 2026
Type: other
Abstract: This thesis explores the question: “Can incorporating transformation strategies within trauma therapies help patients reach deeper existential aspects of their suffering and lead to more effective therapy?”, “Does interpersonal interaction (either therapeutic relationship with a therapist or group dynamics in group psychedelic assisted therapy (PAP)) facilitate the therapeutic process?”, and “How does transformation strategies contribute to accessing deeper layers of pain and meaning in therapy?”. Chapter 1 begins with an introduction, presenting the need for more effective treatments that go beyond symptom reduction to address the deeper layers of patient suffering, given that structured manualized medical-model approaches are not effective for all patients. It then introduces the concepts of existential and transformation strategies/approaches in psychotherapy. Chapter 2 presents a secondary qualitative analysis of 18 psychiatric outpatients with suicidal ideation who participated in 12 sessions of web-based EMDR, a trauma-focused therapy. EMDR was delivered flexibly, with attention to important transformation processes as they arose. Over the course of treatment, three existentially grounded descriptive themes emerged: (1) Self-against-self, (2) The anguish of being, and (3) Existential despair. The findings suggest that many individuals with chronic suicidality face profound existential crises—an aspect rarely addressed in manualized therapies. Chapter 3 is a mixed methods case study demonstrating the personalized use of Multi-modal, Motion-assisted Memory Desensitization and Reconsolidation (3MDR) adapted for the treatment of PTSD, dissociative subtype, with a person with dissociative identity disorder (DID). The standardized protocol was modified through incorporating a titrated, transformative and attachment-informed approach, which was necessary to navigate challenges such as severe relational trauma, emotional dysregulation, and dissociative symptoms preventing access to explicit memories. In addition to improvements in PTSD, anxiety, and depression symptom scores, physical symptoms, and functioning, she reported resolution of existential themes (e.g., increased sense of personal agency) and post-traumatic growth. Analysis of interviews recorded during the follow-up sessions revealed descriptive themes: (1) Synergistic components; (2) Cooling the symptoms of stress and overwhelm; and (3) The joy of self-discovery, capacity and growth. In addition to symptom improvement, the therapeutic process became a pathway for self-discovery and growth, allowing her to be more present in the moment and to reconnect with her body as a source of wisdom. These developments align closely with the most fundamental existential concepts, particularly responsibility, freedom, and the search for meaning. Chapter 4 presents a scoping review of 30 studies on psychedelic-assisted group therapy, including the use of LSD, psilocybin, ketamine, DMT, and MDMA. The majority of the studies used an inner-directed approach to psychotherapy to capitalize on the unique characteristics of psychedelic substances to overcome psychological defenses and improve access to unconscious psychic material. Reported outcomes frequently included profound spiritual or mystical experiences, increased social connectedness, and enriched emotional expression. The findings also indicated improvements such as reduced symptoms of depression, anxiety, and trauma, along with increased self-compassion and access to unconscious content. Overall, the results were largely positive. This therapeutic model emphasizes the participant’s inner healing intelligence (IHI) as the main driver of change, with the therapeutic relationship and group processes supporting self-directed healing and growth (O’Donnell et al., 2024). Chapter 5 concludes with a discussion of the previous chapters, including limitations and implications for future research. In this thesis, the common thread is how a transformative lens was incorporated into EMDR and 3MDR—which gave the treatments more flexibility beyond the strict manual guidelines, and allowed existential themes to come up naturally. In addition, psychedelic assisted therapy, frequently conducted as an inner-directed therapy, may have enhanced potential to address existential themes, with potential extended benefits when in a group based model.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235142304
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: