Work

Pre-registration (code frozen 17 Nov 2026): is the +0.06 eV Co-Ni-V CO-binding shift from short-range order specific to the MACE-MP-0 potential?

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Frozen protocol and code, deposited before any production arm was run. BACKGROUND: in 12 paired Co40Ni40V20(111) slabs, layer-conserving Monte Carlo annealing weakened CO binding by +0.0598 eV at identical surface composition under MACE-MP-0 medium (sign-flip p = 0.00055); a later dose-response test found the shift does not track the degree of ordering (rho = -0.154). All numbers come from one machine-learned potential whose published CO-adsorption error on high-entropy alloys is five to seven times the shift. QUESTION: does the paired, composition-identical CO shift survive fresh seeds under the same potential and an independently trained potential? ARMS: M0 (MACE-MP-0 medium, fresh seeds, 12 pairs), MPA (MACE-MPA-0 medium, 20 pairs), and MH1 (MACE-MH-1, OC20 head oc20_usemppbe, fixed from the model's own head list, 20 pairs; counts toward the verdict only if its licence is cleared). Pair k of every arm starts from the same slab. GATES checked before any adsorption energy is read: stationarity, exact surface-composition identity within pairs, and an ordering contrast; a potential that does not order is INCONCLUSIVE, not a null. DECISION RULE: per arm, REPLICATED (gates pass, positive control detected, positive shift, one-sided sign-flip p < 0.05), ABSENT (gates pass, positive control detected, 95 percent CI upper bound below +0.030 eV) or UNRESOLVED; overall ROBUST, POTENTIAL-DEPENDENT, SEED-FRAGILE or INCONCLUSIVE as defined in the protocol. SMOKE TEST: three one-pair 200-step CPU runs under a throwaway seed confirmed each model loads and per-pair seeding works; their adsorption values were discarded unread. A pre-existing label bug (config field shadowed by the pair index) was fixed; the analysis keys on pair and is unaffected. SCOPE: agreement among MACE potentials shows robustness to the choice of machine-learned potential, not agreement with DFT or experiment; it does not test ordering as the cause, CO2 adsorption, or selectivity.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7235146222
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10